Of all the bizarre recreations of Netflix’s Squid Game, YouTuber MrBeast’s thoughtful and expensive reenactment of the deadly debtor games is the only to have taken the internet by storm in a similar fashion to the original show. The investment in and popularity of his facsimile has been the source of controversy and conversation among fans of the show in past days.
Recommended VideosIn a since-deleted tweet, proud Content Creator and former YouTube employee Jon Youshaei commented on MrBeast’s celebratory reflection post with a widely panned Tweet that missed the point in every way.
Originally published on Sunday, Nov. 28, the tweet remarks:
.@MrBeast Squid Games video: 103M views in 4 days. It took 7 weeks to make.@netflix’s Squid Games series: 111M views in 30 days. It took 10 years (!!) to make.
More views, less time, fewer gatekeepers. That’s the promise of the creator economy.
Or as one tweet rewords Youshaei’s statement: “Rich white man capitalizes on others’ ideas to get a lot of attention! The creator economy!!!!”
I love how this acts like you can pay your bills with views.
"Rich white man capitalizes on others' ideas to get a lot of attention! The creator economy!!!!" https://t.co/z9FS1pEBn8
— Wagatwe Wanjuki 🇰🇪 🇧🇸 (@wagatwe) November 29, 2021Squid Game’s popularity is unprecedented. By the numbers, it’s broken records for not just Korean film, but Netflix globally. It’s the most-watched show on the platform by hours streamed (1.65 billion) and, contrary to Youshaei’s numbers, has been watched by 142 million households in its first four weeks on the platform. At the time of writing, MrBeast’s Squid Game facsimile video has accrued over 122 million views.
One Twitter user helped to contextualize the difference in each success:
you mean it only took 7 weeks for some rich white dude to copy an original concept that poc spent a decade working to get made in a racist gatekept industry & the resulting pale mimicry that was 25 mins & on a free to access platform rode the hype to a bunch of views?? amazing 😑 https://t.co/8h2IUbGqeV
— cunt cunt devil fruit (@catharticus) November 29, 2021The show’s filmmaker Hwang Dong-hyuk, already known for his work in Korean cinema such as the film Silenced (2011), did not have the global platform of a white, US-based content creator riding off the phenomenon of an established IP. Now a household name, the meteoric success of the director and his story is certainly worth celebrating.
Writer Mike Drucker explains how he paved the way in a risk-averse industry.
Was just thinking this. “It took ten years to make the original!” Yes, because nobody thought it would work. “They made a hit YouTube video based on the original in days!” Yes, because now everybody knows it will work
— Mike Drucker (@MikeDrucker) November 29, 2021As has been noted, MrBeast’s recreations are impressive. The work put into recreating each of the show’s iconic sets is laudable — just not original. “Without the actual good concept, he wouldn’t have been able to make this video,” reads one rejoinder to Youshaei.
Is everyone missing that without the actual good concept he wouldn’t have been able to make this video? Creators can expand on artists work, but expecting him to create a series worth recreating is a leap.
— Akilah Hughes (@AkilahObviously) November 29, 2021More tweets shared the sentiment. “I suppose it is easy to succeed when you have a lot of money to spend and other people’s ideas,” reads another comment from Drucker.
Yes, I suppose it is easy to succeed when you have a lot of money to spend and other people’s ideas to use
— Mike Drucker (@MikeDrucker) November 29, 2021And as Gita Jackson has written at Motherboard, MrBeast’s video delights in the same kind of classed violence that Squid Game condemns. MrBeast’s crew can be seen toying with participants throughout the video. All in good fun, until you consider why people play the titular games at all. In Hwang Dong-hyuk’s show, players are recruited from debtors — a uniquely complex societal issue in South Korea that resonates with global audiences.
In the same vein, several of MrBeast’s players told the creator they want to use the prize money to support their families. There was, as in the original, only one final winner. What’s worth celebrating in that?
ncG1vNJzZmivlZy8tcDHoqqcp6aav6awjZympmekq3y0vdSim2afkaKybrLAp6pmm5%2Bjsaa5zWaroZ1dmL%2BmrdOoqWadk6S7sLnYZqCnZZyetKnAjKidZqWil7Kiv9NmraKclaR6tMHCnJysq18%3D